Katzman’s Cinema Komments # 6 - 2/9/08
On the topic of: Unexpected Pleasures of viewing sexy blonde actresses pretending to be Jewish (excluding Marilyn Monroe – who would be 82 now if she was still living — and who converted before she married Arthur Miller, in July 1956, and the stunning Scarlett Johansson, who doesn’t need to) I offer the delectable:
Melanie Griffith
Who, in an interesting example of strategic career choices, decided to make movies about these exotic Biblical people, twice.
In A stranger Among Us (1992), she play a tough cop who goes undercover by assuming the identity of a Hasidic single woman who has ’strayed’ from the sect and then chooses to return to it. This allows her to have no connections to any of the other Hasidic communities in the Northeastern US area and therefore eliminating any way of tracing who she was, if some suspicious person wanted to do that.
She is first introduced as gorgeous, physically competent, brave, very effective with a gun and sexually free young woman, but whose life is going nowhere. She comes across as vaguely unhappy and aimless. But, of course, still well built.
Then a murder occurs in a New York City’s Jewish Hasidic community and she is assigned to find out who did it–a difficult task in the insular, extremely observant religious community.
After she is allowed to live in a kind of dorm as a single woman with no money, and gradually blends in with the sharply gender-divided responsibilities each person assumes, she displays a kind of fascination with what she learns and wonders why the women put up with so many restrictions on their freedom of choice, or in other words, the unrestricted life Melanie is living.
Besides being a murder mystery, the movie is a glimpse into a seldom seen on the screen, every day frozen-in-time world of the Hasids, who also speak Yiddish almost exclusively among themselves, but not around Melanie. Yiddish–a Middle-European dialect that arose about a thousand years ago as millions of Jews gradually migrated north and east from their original Middle Eastern homeland–is a blend of German, Polish and Hebrew. (Read on …)